FounderSync — The Right Co-Founder. The Right Foundation.

Resources

Co-Founder Buyout: How to Value, Vest and Plan for a Founder Leaving

A co-founder buyout is the purchase of a departing founder's shares by the company or the remaining founders. It goes smoothly when the price and process were written down before anyone wanted to leave, and badly when they weren't.

This guide covers the two questions every buyout turns on: which shares are vested, and what the vested ones are worth. Then it walks through the common departure scenarios and the clauses to agree in advance.

This is general information, not legal or tax advice. Buyback rights, leaver terms and payment rules depend on your agreement and the law where your company is registered. Have a lawyer review your terms.

1. Start with vesting

Vesting decides how much of a founder's stake they have earned by the day they leave. A common startup arrangement is four years with a one-year cliff: nothing vests in the first 12 months, 25% vests at the cliff, and the rest vests monthly over the next three years. These are typical terms, not legal requirements; founders can agree other schedules.

Vesting splits every buyout into two separate questions:

  • Unvested shares — under a typical founder vesting arrangement, the company can buy these back, often at the price the founder originally paid. This is usually the simple part.
  • Vested shares — these belong to the departing founder. A buyout here is a real purchase, and the price is where most disputes happen.

If your shares have no vesting at all, every share counts as vested, and a founder who leaves in month three can keep their full stake unless another agreement says otherwise. See the vesting cliff explainer for a month-by-month example.

2. Valuing the vested shares

Early-stage companies rarely have an obvious market price. Pick one of these methods while everyone is still friendly, and write it into your founders' agreement.

Independent fair market value

A valuer both sides accept (or one each, averaged) values the shares at the departure date.

Watch for: Costs money and takes weeks; agree in advance who pays and how the valuer is chosen.

Pre-agreed formula

For example a multiple of trailing revenue or profit, written into the agreement on day one.

Watch for: Simple, but can drift far from reality as the business changes. Review it yearly.

Last priced funding round

Uses the price per share from your most recent equity round as a reference.

Watch for: Investors usually buy preferred shares with extra rights; founder common shares are often worth less than that price.

Book value

Assets minus liabilities from the balance sheet, divided by shares.

Watch for: For most early software companies this is close to zero and ignores growth.

Agreed number, revisited yearly

Founders sign a value each year (a 'certificate of value') that applies if someone leaves.

Watch for: Only works if you actually update it; a stale number causes the same fight later.

Also decide whether a discount applies. A minority stake in a private company is hard to sell, so valuers sometimes reduce its value; founders often agree instead to value shares as a simple proportion of the whole company. Either choice is fine if it's agreed in advance.

3. Good leaver and bad leaver terms

Many agreements set the buyback price by why a founder leaves. A good leaver (resigning on notice, illness, being removed without cause) usually receives fair value for vested shares. A bad leaver (serious misconduct, breaching non-compete or confidentiality terms) may receive less, sometimes only the original price.

Define each category as specific events, not labels. "Leaves to join a competitor within 12 months" is clear; "acts against the company's interests" invites a dispute. How far a bad-leaver discount can go, and whether it is enforceable, depends on the wording and local law.

4. Departure scenarios

Common outcomes under a typical vesting and leaver arrangement. Your agreement decides the real answer.

ScenarioUnvested sharesVested shares
Leaves before the cliffUsually all shares are unvested and are repurchased, often at the original price paid.Typically nothing has vested, so there is nothing to value.
Resigns after the cliff (good leaver)Commonly repurchased at the lower of original cost or fair value.Kept, or bought at fair value if the agreement gives the company or founders that option.
Removed without causeRepurchased; some agreements add partial acceleration as protection.Usually kept or bought at full fair value.
Removed for cause (bad leaver)Repurchased at cost.Some agreements allow a repurchase at a discount; whether that is enforceable depends on the wording and local law.
Death or long-term incapacityOften repurchased, sometimes with acceleration agreed in advance.Often bought from the estate at fair value, sometimes funded by insurance.
Deadlock: founders cannot keep working togetherDepends on who leaves and the leaver category the agreement assigns.A pre-agreed mechanism (independent valuation, or a shotgun clause) sets the price.

For deadlocks, some teams agree a shotgun clause: one founder names a price, and the other must either sell at that price or buy at it. It forces a fair number, but favours whichever founder has more cash to buy.

5. Worked example

A fictional example. Two founders each hold 1,000,000 shares on four-year vesting with a one-year cliff, bought at $0.0001 per share. Founder B resigns as a good leaver after 30 months.

  • Vested: 30 of 48 months → 625,000 shares.
  • Unvested: 375,000 shares, repurchased at cost: 375,000 × $0.0001 = $37.50.
  • Valuation: the agreement uses an independent valuer, who values the company at $800,000 → $0.40 per share with 2,000,000 shares outstanding.
  • Vested buyout price: 625,000 × $0.40 = $250,000, if the company or Founder A exercises its option to buy.
  • Payment: the agreement allows payment over three years, so the company pays about $83,333 a year.

Without the agreement, every one of those lines would be a negotiation, and Founder B could simply keep all 1,000,000 shares.

6. Paying for the buyout

Early companies rarely have spare cash, so decide how a buyout gets funded:

  • Company buyback — the company pays and cancels or holds the shares.
  • Founder purchase — remaining founders buy personally and increase their stake.
  • Instalments — payment over months or years, often with interest and security if a payment is missed.
  • Insurance — some teams insure founders so a buyout after death or incapacity is funded.

Many countries limit when a company may buy back its own shares, for example requiring enough distributable profit or a solvency test. Check the rules where your company is registered before you agree payment terms.

7. Clauses to agree before anyone leaves

  • Vesting schedule and cliff, and whether any acceleration applies on removal or sale.
  • Who has the right (or the obligation) to buy: the company, the remaining founders, or both.
  • Price for unvested shares and price for vested shares, stated separately.
  • Valuation method, who chooses the valuer, and who pays for it.
  • Good and bad leaver definitions, written as concrete events rather than labels.
  • Payment terms: lump sum or instalments, interest, and what happens if the company can't pay.
  • Deadlines: how long the buyer has to exercise the right and to complete the purchase.
  • What the departing founder hands over: IP, accounts, customer relationships, confidentiality.

The founders' agreement generator produces a draft covering vesting and departure terms that you can take to a lawyer.

Co-founder buyout: common questions

How do you value a co-founder's shares in a buyout?

Unvested and vested shares are usually priced differently. Unvested shares are commonly repurchased at the original price paid. Vested shares are valued using the method the founders agreed in advance, such as an independent valuation, a formula, or a yearly agreed value. If nothing was agreed, the founders have to negotiate.

What happens to unvested shares when a co-founder leaves?

In a typical founder vesting arrangement, the company has the right to buy back unvested shares, often at the price the founder paid. Whether that right exists and how it works depends on your agreement and the law where the company is registered.

What is a good leaver and a bad leaver?

They are categories in a founders' or shareholders' agreement that set the buyback price. A good leaver (for example, leaving on good terms or because of illness) usually gets fair value for vested shares. A bad leaver (for example, removal for serious misconduct) may receive less. The exact definitions and their enforceability vary by agreement and jurisdiction.

Can a co-founder be forced to sell their shares?

Only if an agreement gives someone that right, such as a repurchase right over unvested shares or a leaver clause. Without one, a departing founder normally keeps their shares. Get legal advice in your jurisdiction before relying on a forced transfer.

How is a co-founder buyout usually paid for?

From company cash, by the remaining founders personally, or in instalments over time. Many countries restrict when a company may buy back its own shares, for example requiring enough distributable profit or solvency, so check local rules before agreeing payment terms.

Find your differences before you write the clauses

Most buyout disputes start with founders who quietly expected different things: how long they'd stay, when they'd sell, and what leaving early should cost. The free check asks you and your co-founder three of those questions separately, including what you'd do with an early acquisition offer, and shows where your answers differ. Two minutes, three questions, no signup.